Skip to content
J Pouch support charity | Red Lion Group
  • Home
  • About
  • What’s New
  • Resources
  • FORUM
  • Events
  • Contact
  • FAQS
  • MEDIC
  • YouTube
  • Search
Stories

Dysplasia: Surgery or monitoring?

Dysplasia: Surgery of monitoring?

Patients diagnosed with dysplasia are faced with the decision to have surgery to remove the colon because of the risk of developing cancer, Dr Misha Kabir conducted a survey into the factors which affected patients decisions.

Dr Misha Kabir

In most cases dysplasia can be taken out during a colonoscopy (an examination of the large bowel and part of the small one using a flexible tube known as an endoscope). If this process doesn’t work, most medical professionals recommend surgery to remove the large bowel and the fitting of fit a pouch or stoma.

In a recent St Mark’s Hospital survey, which polled 113 responses, (see the December 2018 Roar!page 14) almost two-thirds of patients (64%) diagnosed with dysplasia opted to have surgery while 36% decided not to do so and have regular monitoring instead.

However, 35% of those who had never been diagnosed with dysplasia chose the surgical option, while 30% preferred regular monitoring and a further 35% were uncertain about what they would decide to do.

The reasons respondents gave when considering treatment are shown in Box 1 (below):

Box 1

Survey leader Dr Misha Kabir, Clinical Research Fellow in IBD and Endoscopy at St Mark’s Hospital, told Roar!: “The respondents who preferred surgery were more likely to think that dysplasia progressed to cancer within a year and that colonoscopy surveillance alone would probably not prevent cancer developing in the future.

“Three-quarters of the 47 respondents who had previously been diagnosed with dysplasia felt well informed by their medical teams about the risk of cancer associated with a dysplasia diagnosis and the management options available to them.

“The majority also did not regret the final decision they made to have surgery – or not – for the dysplasia. They also completed a quality-of-life score which on average was the same for the patients who had surgery and those who had not done so.”

The reasons for not feeling well informed are highlighted in Box 2 below:

Box 2

Dr Kabir added: “We hope to address the issues raised in Box 2 and to improve the information and the support we give to patients making these decisions in the future. As always we are grateful for the invaluable role that support groups like Red Lion Group continue to provide to patients making decisions about surgery.”

News

Decision-Making in IBD Dysplasia research

Decision-Making in IBD Dysplasia research

A research team of doctors at St Mark’s Hospital want to speak to people who have had a colectomy and ileoanal pouch due to their inflammatory bowel disease. They particularly want to speak to people who chose to have this surgery due to the finding of changes in the colon lining (called dysplasia). They want to learn how to better communicate and support patients through the process of deciding whether or not to have a colectomy and pouch for this condition. They can only do this if they hear directly from people who have experienced this and can tell them their stories and what worked or didn’t when speaking to their doctors. 

If you are interested in taking part then please do read the information via this weblink. 

Search Resources

Filter Resources

Roar

All Videos

--Information Day 2015

--Information Day 2017

--Information Day 2018

--Information Day 2019

--Zoom 2020

--Zoom 2021

--Zoom 2022

--Zoom 2023

--Zoom 2024

--Zoom 2025

--Zoom 2026

RSS feed: News from St. Mark’s Foundation News from St. Mark’s Foundation

  • Interview with Dr Yaa Danso for Crohn’s and Colitis Awareness Week
  • St Mark’s Clinicians at the European Society of Coloproctology 2026 Scientific Meeting
  • St Mark’s Nurses Share Their Expertise at the Colorectal Genomics Masterclass
  • St Mark’s Consultant Colorectal Surgeon Takes on a Visiting Professorship at the Cleveland Clinic
  • DJ by night, St Mark’s Ambassador by Day: Interview with Saj Shanthakumar
  • St Mark’s Hospital hosts major milestone for surgical innovation with new AI colour mapping tool
  • Donation from The Red Lion Group to Support Ulcerative Colitis Surgical Research
  • Spotlight on Pebs Edwards, ‘Boomers’ Project Research Fellow
  • Conversation with Dr Diya Kapila for Bowel Cancer Awareness Month
  • Interview with Gita Lingam, St Mark’s Research Fellow and Winner of the 2025 John Nicholls Prize for Research

Recent Posts

  • Kangaroo Club Information Day 2026
  • Inspirational stories of living with a J Pouch
  • Life time achievement award for Prof John Nicholls
  • Do the new GLP-1 “slimming” drugs deliver better pouch performance?
  • Pouch irrigation and catheterisation demystified
Privacy | Sitemap
The Red Lion Group is a UK registered charity number 1068124

© Copyright [wpsos_year] The Red Lion Group. All Rights Reserved.

Theme by Colorlib Powered by WordPress
  • Facebook
  • twitter
  • YouTube
Loading Comments...

You must be logged in to post a comment.